Where FSPs often get it wrong - Managing expectations sounds simple, but there are recurring pitfalls that many advisors fall into.

A frequent issue is focusing too much on the premium during sales. While affordability matters, if you gloss over exclusions, waiting periods or disclosure duties, you’re setting the stage for disputes later.

Another mistake is “set and forget” onboarding. Expectation management doesn’t end once a policy is issued. Renewal communications, endorsements and mid-term adjustments all need to be explained carefully to avoid surprises down the line.

Claims are another critical stage. If you reassure a client with “you’ll be covered” without clarifying the policy wording, you create a gap between perception and reality. The PPRs specifically require a claims framework that sets out timelines, escalation procedures and reasons for decisions, a safeguard that helps prevent expectation gaps from spiralling into disputes.

Finally, poor complaints handling can escalate solvable problems. Clients who feel ignored or dismissed often take their grievances further, resulting in reputational harm and regulatory intervention.

Practical tips to manage expectations effectively - So, how can you get this right in practice?

Onboarding: Use a plain language “fact sheet” that sets out the proposed product provider alongside one or two alternatives. Highlight key elements such as insured items (household, motor and optional extras), claims excesses and a high-level summary of exclusions for each provider. Conclude the document with a brief explanation outlining why you recommend the selected provider and ask the client to acknowledge receipt. This creates a compliance record and helps ensure clients understand what to expect from their cover.

Claims: Be proactive at the first notification of loss. Send an email requesting the required documents and map the claims journey for your client with defined turnaround times for each step (acknowledgement, assessment and finalisation). Provide regular updates, even if nothing has changed, because silence fuels frustration.

Renewals: Send communication packs at least 30 days in advance. Highlight any changes clearly and include a "what has changed" summary comparing last year vs. this year. Encourage clients to update their information, such as mileage, security upgrades or renovations.

Ongoing communication: Conduct annual reviews to check if risk details have changed (e.g. new car, change in security or home renovations). You can also send a client education calendar. For example, before hail season, remind clients about storm cover limitations. During high burglary periods, highlight security clauses. This reinforces understanding and shows you care about protecting their interests.

Governance and management information (MI): Use MI dashboards to track repudiations, complaint categories and communication delays. Share these insights with your team and tie them to performance goals. Embedding expectation management into culture makes it second nature rather than a tick-box exercise.

Bringing it back to TCF and COFI - Expectation management is, at its core, about delivering on the principles of TCF. Ask yourself: are your clients getting the information they need at the right time? Do they understand the exclusions? Are they treated fairly throughout the product life cycle?

COFI will elevate these principles into enforceable obligations. You will need to demonstrate, with evidence, that your communication practices are effective. This may mean testing whether clients understood exclusions, monitoring turnaround times for claims and aligning scripts or digital sales tools with the target market.

For you as an FSP, this is both a challenge and an opportunity. By embedding expectation management now, you’ll be better prepared for COFI and benefit from stronger client loyalty and fewer disputes.

Turning compliance into growth - Managing client expectations is not just about avoiding complaints or ticking boxes. It’s about building a resilient business that clients trust.

When you take the time to explain cover, revisit exclusions at renewal and communicate proactively during claims, you do more than meet compliance requirements, you strengthen relationships and set yourself apart in a crowded market.

With regulators sharpening their focus through TCF and the upcoming COFI framework, expectation management will only become more important. Invest in transparent, proactive communication now and you’ll not only reduce compliance risk but also build a foundation for long-term growth.

‍